The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System

Sandra Havel v. Villa St. Joseph et al.

Date Filed	Description
12/10/10 View	Copy of court of appeals order certifying a conflict filed by Villa St. Joseph and Village of Marymount   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
12/13/10	Copy of notice of certified conflict sent to clerk of court of appeals
02/02/11 View	DECISION: It is determined that a conflict exists; parties to brief the issue stated in the court of appeals' journal entry filed 11/22/10
02/02/11 View	Order to clerk of court/custodian to certify record
02/23/11	Record
02/23/11	Clerk's notice of filing of record
02/28/11 View	Request for extension of time to file merit brief   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
View	03/04/11: Granted; merit brief due 4/14/11
04/08/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae State of Ohio in support of appellants   Filed by: State of Ohio
04/11/11 View	Amended brief of amicus curiae State of Ohio in support of appellants   Filed by: State of Ohio
04/14/11 View	Appellant's merit brief   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
04/14/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Association of Civil Trial Attorneys in support of appellant   Filed by: The Ohio Association of Civil Trial Attorneys
04/14/11 View	Brief of amici curiae Ohio Hospital Association et al. in support of appellant   Filed by: Ohio Alliance for Civil Justice   Filed by: Ohio Hospital Association   Filed by: Physicians Insurers Association of America
04/27/11 View	Joint motion to consolidate oral argument date with Case No. 2010-1881   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
View	06/22/11: Denied
05/05/11 View	Memo opposing joint motion to consolidate oral argument date with Case No. 2010-1881   Filed by: Flynn, John   Filed by: Gordon, Judy
05/09/11 View	Memo opposing joint motion to consolidate oral argument date with Case No. 2010-1881   Filed by: Havel, Sandra
05/16/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Association for Justice in support of appellee   Filed by: Ohio Association for Justice
05/16/11 View	Appellee's merit brief   Filed by: Havel, Sandra
06/02/11 View	Reply brief of amicus curiae State of Ohio   Filed by: State of Ohio
06/03/11 View	Reply brief   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
07/08/11	Oral argument scheduled for Tuesday, September 20, 2011
07/14/11 View	Notice of oral argument to be held on Tuesday, September 20, 2011
08/04/11 View	Motion to reschedule oral argument   Filed by: Havel, Sandra
View	08/12/11: Granted; oral argument is rescheduled for Wednesday, September 21, 2011
08/10/11 View	Response to motion to reschedule oral argument   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
08/12/11	Oral argument rescheduled for Wednesday, September 21, 2011
08/12/11 View	Notice of oral argument to be held Wednesday, September 21, 2011
08/17/11 View	Joint motion of appellants and amicus curiae State of Ohio for divided oral argument time   Filed by: State of Ohio   Filed by: Villa St. Joseph   Filed by: Village of Marymount
View	09/02/11: Granted; amicus curiae State of Ohio shall share the time allotted to appellants
09/21/11	Oral argument held
02/15/12 View	DECISION: Certified Question Answered in the negative and the judgment of the court of appeals is reversed. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-552.
02/29/12	Return of record to clerk of court/custodian
03/05/12	Return receipt - Postage $16.07
03/06/12	Certified copy of judgment entry/mandate sent to clerk