The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System

Acordia of Ohio, LLC v. Michael Fishel, Janice Freytag, Mark Taber, Sheila Diefenbach, Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC, Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc., and Joseph T. Lukens

Date Filed	Description
01/28/11 View	Notice of appeal of Acordia of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
01/28/11 View	Memorandum in support of jurisdiction   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
01/28/11 View	Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. in support of appellant   Filed by: The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.
01/31/11	Copy of notice of appeal sent to clerk of court of appeals
01/31/11 View	Jurisdictional memorandum of amici curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce et al. in support of appellant   Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce   Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council   Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.   Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
02/28/11 View	Memorandum in response   Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila   Filed by: Fishel, Michael   Filed by: Freytag, Janice   Filed by: Lukens, Joseph   Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC   Filed by: Taber, Mark
04/20/11 View	DECISION: Appeal accepted
04/20/11 View	Order to clerk of court/custodian to certify record
04/20/11 View	Citation to relevant authority   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
04/28/11	Record
04/28/11	Clerk's notice of filing of record
06/06/11 View	Stipulation to extension of time to 6/27/11 to file merit brief   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11 View	Appellant's merit brief   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11	Supplement to brief   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce, Ohio Chemistry Technology Council, USI Holdings Corp., USI Midwest, Inc., Willis of Ohio, Inc., and Hylant Group, Inc. in support of appellant   Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.   Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce   Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council   Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.   Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.   Filed by: Willis of Ohio, Inc.
06/27/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. in support of appellant   Filed by: The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.
07/01/11 View	Stipulation to extension of time to 8/16/11 to file merit brief   Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila   Filed by: Fishel, Michael   Filed by: Freytag, Janice   Filed by: Lukens, Joseph   Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC   Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/15/11 View	Brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Employment Lawyers' Association in support of appellees   Filed by: The Ohio Employment Lawyers' Association
08/15/11 View	Appellees' merit brief   Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila   Filed by: Fishel, Michael   Filed by: Freytag, Janice   Filed by: Lukens, Joseph   Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC   Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/25/11	Oral argument scheduled for Tuesday, November 15, 2011
08/31/11 View	Notice of oral argument to be held Tuesday, November 15, 2011
09/06/11 View	Reply brief   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
09/06/11 View	Reply brief of Amici Curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce, Ohio Chemistry Technology Council, USI Holdings Corp., USI Midwest, Inc., Willis of Ohio, Inc., and Hylant Group, Inc.   Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.   Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce   Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council   Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.   Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.   Filed by: Willis of Ohio, Inc.
11/15/11	Oral argument held
05/24/12 View	DECISION: Affirmed. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-2297. (Slip Opinion)
06/04/12 View	Motion for reconsideration   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
View	07/25/12: Granted; the court will be reviewing the merits of this case. The parties shall not file additional briefs.
06/04/12 View	Memorandum of amici curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce et al. in support of reconsideration   Filed by: Cintas Corporation   Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.   Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce   Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council   Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.   Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
06/04/12 View	Memorandum of amici curiae Professors Sean K. Mangan and John A. Barrett Jr. in support of reconsideration   Filed by: Barrett, John   Filed by: Mangan, Sean
06/14/12 View	Memo opposing motion for reconsideration   Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila   Filed by: Fishel, Michael   Filed by: Freytag, Janice   Filed by: Lukens, Joseph   Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC   Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/17/12 View	Motion for oral argument   Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila   Filed by: Fishel, Michael   Filed by: Freytag, Janice   Filed by: Lukens, Joseph   Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.   Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC   Filed by: Taber, Mark
View	09/05/12: Denied
08/23/12 View	Memo opposing motion for oral argument   Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
10/11/12 View	DECISION: Reversed and remanded. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-4648. (Slip Opinion)
10/24/12	Return of record to clerk of court/custodian
10/26/12	Certified copy of judgment entry/mandate sent to clerk
10/31/12	Return receipt; Postage $24.40 (Box 1 of 3)
10/31/12	Return receipt; Postage $20.45 (Box 2 of 3)
11/05/12	Return receipt; Postage $23.82 (Box 3 of 3)
12/06/12	Copy of reconsideration entry sent to clerk