County Engineers Association of Ohio
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Vierow, Frederick (5185)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Flexible Pavements, Inc.
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Barger, Brian (18908)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Fadel, Timothy (77531)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Ohio Aggregates and Industrial Minerals Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Barger, Brian (18908)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Ohio Contractors Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Devine, Patrick (22919)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Ohio Equipment Dealers Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Breitfeller, Ralph (17579)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Ohio Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Rhoads, Jennifer (70049)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Ohio Ready Mix Concrete Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Barger, Brian (18908)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
The American Council of Engineering Companies of Ohio
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Rosenberg, Thomas (24898)
, Counsel of Record
Traven, Michael (81158)
|
|
County Commissioners Association of Ohio
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Luebbers, Thomas (16916)
, Counsel of Record
Linnenbom, Victor (86936)
|
|
Ohio Municipal League
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Luebbers, Thomas (16916)
, Counsel of Record
Linnenbom, Victor (86936)
|
|
Ohio School Boards Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Luebbers, Thomas (16916)
, Counsel of Record
Linnenbom, Victor (86936)
|
|
The Ohio Manufacturers Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Engel, Mark (19486)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
The Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Engel, Mark (19486)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
Beaver Excavating Company
(Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Ridgley, Thomas (910)
, Counsel of Record
Ehler, Anthony (39304)
Krummen, Robert (76996)
Miller, Jeffrey (72702)
|
|
Levin, Richard A.
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Carney, Stephen (63460)
, Counsel of Record
Brigner, Julie (66367)
DeWine, Richard (9181)
Hampton, Matthew (0)
Hubbard, Barton (23141)
|
|
| Date Filed |
Description |
09/09/11
View
|
Notice of appeal of Beaver Excavating Company, et al.
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
09/09/11
View
|
Memorandum in support of jurisdiction
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
09/09/11
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae County Engineers Association in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
County Engineers Association of Ohio |
|
09/09/11
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae Ohio Contractors Association in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Contractors Association |
|
09/09/11
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae Ohio Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Petroleum Marketers and Convenience Store Association |
|
09/09/11
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 |
|
| 09/12/11
|
Copy of notice of appeal sent to clerk of court of appeals
|
10/11/11
View
|
Memorandum in response
|
12/21/11
View
|
DECISION: Appeal accepted
|
12/21/11
View
|
Order to clerk of court/custodian to certify record
|
| 01/20/12
|
Record
|
| 01/20/12
|
Clerk's notice of filing of record
|
01/30/12
View
|
Notice of appearance of Stephen P. Carney as counsel of record
|
02/03/12
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Matthew P. Hampton
|
View
|
02/16/12: Granted; counsel shall file a notice of permission to appear pro hac vice with Attorney Services within 30 days
|
02/07/12
View
|
Stipulation to extension of time to 3/20/12 to file merit brief
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
03/19/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae County Engineers Association of Ohio in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
County Engineers Association of Ohio |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
International Union of Operating Engineers, Local 18 |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae The American Council of Engineering Companies of Ohio in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
The American Council of Engineering Companies of Ohio |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Contractors Association in support of appellants
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Contractors Association |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Appellants' merit brief
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Appendix to appellants' merit brief - volume I of II
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Appendix to appellants' merit brief - volume II of II
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
| 03/20/12
|
Supplement to brief
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Brief of amici curiae the Ohio Aggregates and Industrial Mineral Association, Flexible Pavements, Inc., and Ohio Ready Mix Concrete Association in support of appellants
| |
Filed by: |
Flexible Pavements, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Aggregates and Industrial Minerals Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Ready Mix Concrete Association |
|
03/20/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Equipment Dealers Association in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Equipment Dealers Association |
|
03/27/12
View
|
Stipulation to extension of time to file merit brief to 5/9/12
|
04/02/12
View
|
Joint motion to schedule oral argument on the same day as 2011-1757
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
| |
Filed by: |
Levin, Richard |
|
View
|
04/19/12: Granted
|
05/09/12
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Manufacturers' Association and The Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
The Ohio Manufacturers Association |
| |
Filed by: |
The Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants |
|
05/09/12
View
|
Appellee's merit brief
|
05/09/12
View
|
Brief of amici curiae County Commissioners Association of Ohio, Ohio Municipal League and Ohio School Boards Association in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
County Commissioners Association of Ohio |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Municipal League |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio School Boards Association |
|
| 05/25/12
|
Oral argument scheduled for Wednesday, July 11, 2012
|
05/25/12
View
|
Notice of oral argument to be held on Wednesday, July 11, 2012
|
05/29/12
View
|
Reply brief
| |
Filed by: |
Beaver Excavating Company |
|
05/29/12
View
|
Reply brief of amicus curiae County Engineers Association of Ohio
| |
Filed by: |
County Engineers Association of Ohio |
|
05/29/12
View
|
Reply brief of amici curiae The Ohio Aggregates and Industrial Mineas Association et al.
| |
Filed by: |
Flexible Pavements, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Aggregates and Industrial Minerals Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Ready Mix Concrete Association |
|
05/29/12
View
|
Reply brief of amicus curiae Ohio Contractors Association
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Contractors Association |
|
05/29/12
View
|
Reply brief of amicus curiae Ohio Equipment Dealers Association
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Equipment Dealers Association |
|
07/03/12
View
|
List of additional authorities
|
| 07/11/12
|
Oral argument held
|
12/07/12
View
|
DECISION: Reversed and remanded. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-5776. (Slip Opinion)
|